The anti-immigration rhetoric, which somehow got wedged in the whole health care reform debate, is making it mighty hard for Hispanic conservatives to wave the GOP flag with pride.
First there was Congressman Joe Wilson’s (R-SC) infamous “You lie,” outburst, after President Obama said illegal immigrants wouldn’t be covered under a new health care plan. Wilson’s outburst prompted Ivan Marte, the ex-chairman of the Rhode Island Republican Hispanic Assembly to leave the Republican Party. On Monday, Marte told The Providence Journal that Wilson’s behavior was “shameful” and “uncivilized.”
In a letter to GOP Chairman Giovanni Cicione, Marte wrote, “I do hope that my resignation served as a sign, that the Republican Party in this Nation need to reevaluate their position,” on reaching out to minorities.
Then there’s the matter of the debate swirling around the Baucus Health Plan, which liberal Democrats are using as an opportunity to sway Hispanic voters.
In the Baucus plan, which capitulated to Republican demands, proof of citizenship would be required before someone could buy personal insurance coverage through the state exchange. Essentially, this would bar illegal immigrants from purchasing health insurance with their own money. Even legal immigrants in the U.S. less than five years would be restricted from purchasing health insurance through the National Health Exchange.
Not only is this plan so mean-spirited it would make the Grinch blush, it’s bad fiscally. Congressman Mike Honda (D-CA), put it best in a September 22 special to Roll Call, when he asked, “how fiscally rational is it to exclude individuals willing and able to share in the responsibility of paying into the system?”
Honda isn’t the only liberal Democrat who’s starting to look mighty appealing to Hispanic conservatives.
On Wednesday, “House liberals” urged Democratic leaders to tone down language in the Senate health care legislation that “limits legal and illegal immigrants’ access to medical care,” Roll Call reported.
The anti-immigrant rhetoric is also turning-off Hispanic evangelicals. Rev. Nick Garza, chief operating officer of the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference (NHCLC), told The Christian Post that demanding proof of citizenship in order to purchase Health Insurance was, “a defacto endorsement of racial profiling.”
Immigration reform is a sensitive topic for many Hispanic Americans. Marte’s recent departure from the GOP, coupled with the vociferous anti-immigration rhetoric, is discouraging for Hispanic conservatives.
Hispanics are the largest and fastest-growing minority group in the U.S. and as we all know, Barack Obama won the 2008 presidential election with nearly two-thirds of the Hispanic vote. One reason he was able to take such a large portion of the Hispanic vote had to do with his stance on immigration.
It’s a shame Democrats are able to demagogue on this issue because once you get past the immigration issue, many core Republican beliefs are appealing to Hispanic voters. Issues like faith, family, and a strong defense policy are important to many Hispanics.
If the GOP hopes for a big comeback, it would behoove Republican leaders to ease up on the anti-immigrant rhetoric.
Naira Ruiz is a regular contributor to The D.C. Writeup



