For Feminism, A Pair of Pyrrhic Victories

Posted on 04 October 2009 by Shauna Moser
Print This Article Print This Article Email This Article Email This Article

VN:F [1.5.8_856]
Rating: -1 (from 5 votes)

Feminists everywhere, rejoice! Your day has finally come! The groundwork laid by the Suffragettes, sown by the bra-burning flower womyn of the 60s, fertilized by the sexual liberation of the 70s, and watered by Roe v. Wade has finally borne fruit! The glass ceiling is shattered! Women are finally in a position to … sexually harass other women? Women are finally in a position to … find their husbands (or fathers … or brothers) without jobs?

In two honest-to-goodness, not-making-this-stuff-up stories this week, the USA Today and the legal blog Above the Law have covered two stories that should make feminists cringe, not rejoice. But rejoice is exactly what they’re doing.

In a story that makes normal people blush, but has made some bloggers a little *ahem* hot-and-bothered, a Delaware law firm has been hit with a sexual harassment suit after they failed to deal with creatively titled “girl-on-girl sexual harassment.” In this case, a female partner allegedly sexually harassed a female associate in the firm, telling her sexually explicit things that I don’t really feel comfortable repeating here. Some commentators admitted that this illustrates that “women can be just as creepy as men” and “just as capable of creating a threatening work environment” at the same time. Others have used the story to show that career women are finally in a position to “break from the stereotypical harassment situation of a female victim going up against an old boys’ network.” Depicting this story as a boon for the women’s movement disgusts me.

The other story is less perverse, but no less disheartening. In a banner week for feminists, the USA Today also reports that the recession has hit men the hardest, where of the 6.4 million jobs lost this year, 26% of those jobs were lost by women and a whopping 74% of those jobs were lost by men. The story cites to the fact that a lot of the jobs “typically” performed by men, such as construction and manufacturing, are part of industries hardest hit by the recession, whereas “women’s jobs,” like health care, education and local government, are being laid off less (some even seeing growth) and are receiving the most stimulus money.

Instead of raising the concern that perhaps these women are now going to have to work two jobs to support their family or considering the psychological effects this may have on men (and the negative impact these statistics may have on women because of their husbands’ unemployed status), feminists see this as a good thing. The President of the Institute for Women’s Policy Research (as a side note – is there an Institute for Men’s Policy Research?) actually stated, “It was a long historical slog to get to this point.” Another woman, who wrote a book often used in feminist study classes entitled Creating Rosie the Riveter, was cited as saying that “the image that the man has to be the breadwinner has changed.”

So congratulations, feminists, you now have equality. But equality at what expense?

This is really another example of people who are trying to “help” or trying to “represent the voiceless” completely losing touch with reality. Is having the equal opportunity to harass another human being really a boon for the feminist movement? Is having males lose more jobs than females really the equal opportunity that the Suffragettes imagined? Neither of these stories are good situations for anyone. These are things you wouldn’t wish on humanity in general, let alone on an entire gender. They shouldn’t be seen as a boon to the women’s equality movement, they should be seen for exactly what they are: tragic events that affect and damage everyone together. That’s equality.

Bookmark and Share

Related Articles

  1. Women Evolving into Beauties, Male Creationists Repent
  2. By the Content of Her Character
  3. Pennsylvania Man Gets 120 Years for Child Porn

1 Comments For This Post

  1. Vote -1 Says:

    I confess, I don’t exactly understand the argument you’re making. You ask two questions: “Is having the equal opportunity to harass another human being really a boon for the feminist movement? Is having males lose more jobs than females really the equal opportunity that the Suffragettes imagined? Neither of these stories are good situations for anyone.”

    Taking the first question, what do you really mean? By acquiring more jobs for women, apparently feminists have created situations where a woman is in a position to harass a female employee…why is this the fault of feminists? If women weren’t in management positions, men would have those jobs…surely some of them would harass others, no? Are you really arguing that more women in management will _increase_ sexual harassment in the workplace? On what grounds? Or are you arguing that feminists shouldn’t have pushed for more women in management to protect women from themselves…that way, women who would harass others if given the opportunity would be protected from doing so? Is that really your argument?

    The second question you raise I find even more baffling. In an economic downturn, some sectors will lose more jobs than others. If only men were employed, we would not see any gender gap. If men and women were equally employed in every occupation (as it would be if we had some kind of awful, forced-quota system of 50-50 men-women in every occupation), presumably we would not see any gender gap. As it is, as you correctly note, men are more likely to serve in certain sectors, and women in others. Depending on the nature of the depression, some sectors will lose more jobs. If those jobs happen to be sectors that employ more men, more men will end up unemployed than women. Are you alleging that women have engineered a massive economic depression and targeted it at those sectors that employ more men? If so, what evidence can you present? And if not, why would you blame women, suggesting that they’ve “wished” widespread unemployment on men? I think it’s pretty obvious that men and women all over this country are impacted by the depression, and would not wish its ill effects on anyone. Why, then, are women being blamed for something? Is it because a few feminists have noted that it’s nice that we are no longer living in a society where women would have been likelier laid off because their bosses would assume their husbands would provide for them? I wouldn’t say any of the quotations you presented show unnatural insensitivity towards men–simply women who are glad that there truly is equality. Would it be better, in your estimation, for them to encourage women across America to instruct their employers to lay them off, so that more men are allowed to keep their jobs? On what grounds?

    I’m sorry, I can agree that there are occasions where especially militant feminism goes too far. But nothing in this piece suggests that you have any justifiable criticisms to levy against feminists, based on the points you’ve raised and the evidence you’ve presented.

    [Reply to this Comment]

1 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Vote -1 Says:

    [...] 6, 2009 in media From The D.C. Writeup;- Feminists everywhere, rejoice! Your day has finally come! The groundwork laid by the [...]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a
video comment.

What We’re Reading

Weapons industry can't keep up with demand for ammunition
Read more at www.chron.com

People live in the flood tunnels underneath Las Vegas
Read more at www.thesun.co.uk

Indian lunar mission discovers water on moon
Read more at www.timesonline.co.uk

Italian Police seize 'Croc' from mobster's home
Read more at www.earthtimes.org

Fidel Casto Praises Obama's Green Speech
Read more at google.com

Tom DeLay Dances?
Read more at politico.com

Obama the Impotent
Read more at guardian.co.uk

Obama's History with ACORN
Read more at online.wsj.com

Glenn Beck Says McCain Would Have Been Worse Than Obama
Read more at politico.com

Lead Scientists Denounce Global Warming
Read more at vancouversun.com

Jessica Simpson's Dog Raped and Murdered
Read more at people.com

Barack Obama's television marathon
Read more at politico.com

Obama Takes Media to Task for Coverage of Racial Controversy, Wilson
Read more at foxnews.com

Blue Dog Democrats eye new financial reform
Read more at politico.com

Iranian president angers the West over Holocaust comments before he heads to a UN general assembly meeting in New York
Read more at foxnews.com

South Africa athletics authority knew of Caster Semenya's internal testes before the world championships in Berlin
Read more at foxnews.com

Obama ready to dramatically reduce nuclear arsenal before he chairs a UN security council meeting
Read more at guardian.co.uk

4 year old shares cocaine with peers at day care after father tells him its candy
Read more at foxnews.com

Obama criticizes major media outlets while making appearances on several Sunday morning talk shows
Read more at newsbusters.org

Manhunt for suspect in brutal family murder that left wife and 5 young children dead
Read more at foxnews.com

Hofstra 'gang rape' consensual
Read more at foxnews.com

NFL favors GOP over Dems
Read more at politico.com

Cadaver to be discovered on Garrido property?
Read more at cnn.com

Town installs cameras to track all cars entering and exiting
Read more at seattletimes.nwsource.com

Implanted tooth brings sight to blind woman
Read more at breitbart.com

Police make arrest in Yale murder case
Read more at abcnews.go.com

Delay Injured 'Dancing With the Stars'
Read more at cnn.com

Sen. Snowe Will Not Support Baucus Bill
Read more at corner.nationalreview.com

"We cannot live under the shadow of an Iran with nuclear weapons"
Read more at ace.mu.nu

Is there a sharp divide between the ideological right and mainstream media?
Read more at politico.com

Conservative book boasting big sales despite being ignored by liberal critics
Read more at cnsnews.com

Ozone layer hole smaller in 2009 than in 2008
Read more at breitbart.com

U.S. and Europe disagree over new climate change treaty
Read more at guardian.co.uk

Former President Carter thinks Wilson's outburst is rooted in racism
Read more at foxnews.com

White House collects web users' information without notification
Read more at washingtontimes.com

House of Reps releases guidelines for presidential put-downs
Read more at politico.com

Superintendent pressured to resign for not showing Obama's school speech
Read more at valdostadailytimes.com

Mortar fire hits green zone in Iraq during Biden visit
Read more at washingtontimes.com

Panel to recommend changes to current color-coded terror-alert system
Read more at washingtontimes.com

The left plays the race card AGAIN- this time about Joe Wilson's outburst
Read more at foxnews.com

Blagojevich blames federal prosecutor for former aide's death
Read more at washingtontimes.com

Taliban's IEDs harder to detect and deadlier than ever before
Read more at washingtontimes.com

Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff calls for more U.S. troops in Afghan War
Read more at washingtontimes.com

Biden makes surprise trip to Iraq
Read more at washingtontimes.com

Senior al Qaeda operative killed by U.S. forces
Read more at cnn.com

School bus beating appears racially motivated
Read more at stltoday.com

Patrick Swayze loses battle with cancer
Read more at examiner.com

Wilson Defends Outburst, Says He Will Not Apologize on House Floor
Read more at foxnews.com

A Health Insurance Mandate That Works Like Auto Insurance? Think Again
Read more at foxnews.com

Obama tries to reinvigorate Wall Street reform
Read more at washingtonpost.com

Democrats see race factor for Barack Obama foes
Read more at politico.com

The great myth: bipartisanship
Read more at politico.com

House Prepares for a Vote on Rebuking Wilson
Read more at nytimes.com

At Least 19 Killed in Ramadan Food Stampede
Read more at nytimes.com

Obama delivers “major” speech on financial crisis
Read more at foxnews.com

Bin Laden calls out Obama
Read more at bostonherald.com

Dead at 60, R.I.P Punk Icon Jim Carroll
Read more at rollingstone.com

Obama on Bush's Turf
Read more at foxnews.com

REWARD: 1 million to recover missing Warhol pieces
Read more at ktla.com

American citizens see through media distortion
Read more at people-press.org

Even fellow inmates show no mercy for Nancy Garrido
Read more at cbsnews.com

Watch Kanye being a horrible person!
Read more at huffingtonpost.com

Body of Missing Yale Student Turns Up in Wall
Read more at cnn.com

Teenager vows abstinence, refuses Gardisil shot, and is denied immigration
Read more at abcnews.go.com

Six construction workers plunge to death in Hong Kong
Read more at news.yahoo.com

An estimated 1 million people flock to DC to protest against Obama
Read more at dailymail.co.uk

World's oldest living person dies at age 115
Read more at breitbart.com

Undercover pimp and hooker catch ACORN again in NYC
Read more at nypost.com

Summer temps below average in US
Read more at noaanews.noaa.gov

Pro-Life Activist shot in front of Michigan school
Read more at mlive.com

South Africa threatens Third World War over Caster gender case
Read more at thesun.co.uk

Venezuelan President Chavez visits Russia to discuss arms, energy deals
Read more at alertnet.org

New pictures of 9-11 mastermind could spur more attacks against U.S.
Read more at foxnews.com





Writeup's Best

  • No results available

Subscribe

Subscribe RSSSubscribe comments RSSFollow me on Twitter


The Writeup Poll

Does ACORN hire corrupt employees or does ACORN corrupt them?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Sites We Like